Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

link
Late-autumn gardens beside a cream-sided porch and neighboring stone home in an established Pennsylvania neighborhood.

How Bethlehem Property Taxes Work on Each Side of the County Line

If you're comparing two Bethlehem homes, the tax rates can look alarming. A house on the Northampton County side of the city carries a school millage of 65.53 for the 2026-27 school year. A house on the Lehigh County side carries 20.33. The city's own 2026 rates follow the same pattern: 19.64 mills in Northampton County and 6.21 in Lehigh County.

Now look at the bills. The Morning Call reported on Nov. 6, 2026, that the average Northampton-side property, assessed at $57,100, pays about $1,121 a year in city tax. The Lehigh-side property it used as an example, assessed at $160,900, pays about $999. In those examples, the Northampton millage is roughly three times higher, and the assessment is roughly one-third the size. City and school rates are set to match the way each county measures value. County taxes don't work that way, and the 2027 county budgets are now pulling the two sides of Bethlehem in different directions.

Two Counties, Two Measuring Sticks

Bethlehem is unusual among Pennsylvania cities. About one-third of its area is in Lehigh County and two-thirds is in Northampton County. The City of Bethlehem explains that the two counties use different base years to assess property, which is why the city charges a different millage on each side.

The base years are far apart. lehighvalleylive.com reported that Lehigh County calculates taxes on 100% of fair market value as of 2013, the year of its last countywide reassessment. Northampton County bases its millage on 50% of a property's value and last reassessed countywide in 1995. In Northampton County, newer homes are assessed with a formula that prorates them back to the same 50% of 1995 value, according to lehighvalleylive.com's coverage of County Executive Tara Zrinski's budget.

The state tracks how far assessments have drifted from sale prices. The State Tax Equalization Board's 2025 common level ratios, published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin on June 6, 2026, are 47.0 for Lehigh County and 16.1 for Northampton County. Each ratio is the median of assessment-to-sale-price ratios for valid 2025 sales in that county. So a typical Northampton County home that sold in 2025 carried an assessment equal to about 16% of its price, and a typical Lehigh County home carried about 47%. The Board states that these ratios are meant only for assessment appeals and apply from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027.

That explains the size of the millage gap. Each county measures value on a very different scale, so each taxing body has to set a different rate to raise money fairly from both sides.

The School District Does the Balancing

The Bethlehem Area School District collects the largest part of the bill, and its budget shows exactly how it divides the cost between the two counties. The district's 2026-27 real estate tax rate report labels the method "Multi-County Rebalancing" under Section 672.1 of the School Code. First, the district divides its levy according to each county's share of market value. Then it sets each side's millage against that county's own assessed values.

BASD 2026-27 figures Lehigh side Northampton side
Assessed value $1,698,445,500 $2,872,482,100
2024 STEB market value $2,045,342,664 $11,149,601,045
Share of district market value 15.50096% 84.49904%
Tax levy needed $34,533,026 $188,246,891
2025-26 millage 19.42 63.17
2026-27 millage 20.33 65.53

The Northampton side holds about 63% of the district's assessed value and about 84.5% of its market value. The levy follows market value. Since Northampton-side assessments are small compared with what the homes are worth, the millage has to be high to collect that share. The high Northampton-side rate and the low Northampton-side assessment come from the same calculation, so neither one tells you much by itself.

The city follows the same logic in its own rates, which is why the Morning Call's two average bills land within about $120 of each other.

Three Bills, Side by Side

Applying the current rates to the two average city assessments gives the full picture. These are the city's reported average assessed properties on each side, not matched homes, and the school figures come before any homestead exclusion.

Annual tax Northampton side, $57,100 assessed Lehigh side, $160,900 assessed
City, 2026 19.64 mills, about $1,121 6.21 mills, about $999
County, 2026 10.8 mills, about $617 3.78 mills, about $608
School, 2026-27 65.53 mills, about $3,742 20.33 mills, about $3,271

The combined rate is 95.97 mills on the Northampton side and 30.32 mills on the Lehigh side. Those totals look very different on paper. On the average assessments above, each line of the bill comes out much closer.

Where 2027 Pulls the Two Sides Apart

County taxes are the one part of the bill that nobody balances across the county line. Each county taxes only its own side and sets its rate for its own budget. For 2027, the two counties are moving at different speeds.

Lehigh County has decided. On Oct. 28, 2026, commissioners adopted an amended 2027 budget that raises the county rate from 3.78 to 4.41 mills, a 16.7% increase. The Morning Call reported that it passed 7-2, with Commissioners Antonio Pineda and Zachary Cole-Borghi voting no. Commissioner Sarah Fevig's amendment for 4.31 mills was voted down. On the $160,900 Lehigh-side assessment, the county line rises from about $608 to about $710.

Northampton County is still deciding. Executive Tara Zrinski has proposed raising the county rate from 10.8 to 15.5 mills, a 43.5% increase. lehighvalleylive.com reported that she put the cost for the average resident at about $24.19 more per month and listed inflation, employee benefits, pensions, and the operating needs of Gracedale, the county nursing home, among the reasons. Lehigh Valley Public Media reported that county council will hold a public hearing at 6:30 p.m. Dec. 3 at the Government Center in Easton and could vote that night. The county's proposed 2027 budget sets Dec. 17, 2026, as the adoption deadline. If council adopts the full proposal, the county line on the $57,100 Northampton-side assessment would rise from about $617 to about $885.

The city's proposal treats both sides evenly. Mayor J. William Reynolds presented a proposed 2027 budget at the ArtsQuest Creative Factory on West Third Street. It includes a 2.9% city tax increase, to 20.21 mills on the Northampton side and 6.39 on the Lehigh side. The Morning Call reported an average increase of about $32.50 a year. The city sets both rates together, so its change lands at about the same percentage on each side.

The city and school rates are set to match the way each county measures value. The county portion depends on decisions by the two counties, and the 2027 budgets would affect the example assessments above differently.

The 1995 base stays in place for 2027. Zrinski is adding two commercial assessors to improve the county's property data, and she has said the 1995 base raises questions about whether assessments are accurate and fair. At the state level, The Morning Call reported in August that regular reassessment is a top priority of the County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania. It quoted executive director Kyle Kopko: "It is just making sure everyone is being treated fairly."

Comparing Bethlehem Homes on Taxes

Since the millage depends on which county a home is in, and the assessment depends on when and how the county valued it, the useful comparison is the actual bill. Here's what to check when you look at homes on both sides of town:

  1. Confirm the county. The city line doesn't tell you which county a home is in, and the county decides which column of rates applies.
  2. Compare dollars. Two homes at similar prices can carry quite different assessments, especially in Northampton County, where values still trace back to 1995.

The state allocated $8,377,304.43 in property tax relief to the Bethlehem Area School District for 2026-27, delivered through homestead and farmstead exclusions.

This is general information and not tax, legal, or financial advice. Please confirm the details for your own situation with your county assessment office or a qualified tax professional.

A Few Quick Questions

How do the example bills compare? On the average assessments above, each line of the bill comes out much closer than the millage rates suggest. The assessments are not matched homes.

Do both sides attend the same school district? Yes. The Bethlehem Area School District covers both, and its 2026-27 rates are set together through the rebalancing method described above.

When were 2026 city taxes due? For the 2026 tax year, the City of Bethlehem gave a discount for bills paid in full before March 31, and payment was due by May 29.

If you're weighing homes on both sides of Bethlehem, we'd be glad to work through the numbers with you at your pace. Michael and Ed at The Grateful Agent can help you compare actual bills before you decide, and our home valuation page is a good place to start. Contact Us whenever you're ready.

Work With Us

Our team brings deep Pennsylvania expertise, honest guidance, and a genuine investment in every client outcome. We are not just here to close deals — we are here to help you make one of the biggest decisions of your life with confidence.

Follow Me on Instagram